×
Home
2021 Conference
All Conferences
Instructions
Contacts & Support
TSVC | Tourism Students Virtual Conference

Barriers Faced By a Disabled Tourist

Barriers Faced By a Disabled Tourist
Author: Grace O'Sullivan
1 Commentries
This paper aims to highlight and review the barriers faced by a disabled person, in relation to tourism.

According to the Disability discrimination Act 1995 a disabled person is defined as somebody who has a physical or mental impairment that has a substantial and long term adverse effect on their ability to carry out normal day to day activities. (Directgov 2010)

According to Disability facts 2009; 60 million people worldwide are living with disability, which equals to 10-20% of a countries population having a disability. Figures also show that 8 million disabled people in Europe take trips aboard at least once a year. The figures show that people with disabilities are important customers among the travel industry, so it is important that tourism suppliers are able to recognize the needs of people with disabilities.

From the literature on the subject of disability and travel it has become clear that people with disabilities have the same desires to travel as someone without a disability. However particatipation in tourism requires many elements such as physical, mental and social. These elements can be compromised by someone with a disability.

The literature on tourism and disabilities mainly focuses on the experiences of the mobility impaired. However work done by a group of researchers in Hong Kong carried research out on people with mobility and vision impairments. They found that entry or re-entry into tourism requires fives stages: the first stage is the Personal stage; at this stage priorities lay in the recovery and rehabilitation, tourism is seen as impossible at this stage. The second stage is reconnection; this is the period of self discovery. The third stage is travel analysis stage; this stage involves weighing up the possibilities of travel. The fourth stage is the physical journey; people with disabilities need to make compromises and adopt a number of strategies in order to manage and enjoy their tourism experience. Tourist will have to overcome the environmental and interactive barriers at this stage. The final stage is Reflection Stage; the final stage is the reflection of the trip which may in fact determine whether the individual will travel again. A positive experience will build confidence and a negative experience may inhibit any future tourism activity.

In the book Tourism as a modern synthesis it has been identified that people with disabilities will face a number of barriers , which can be sub categorized into two main barriers; Internal barriers ( these barriers happen before the trip) and Exogenous barriers (these barriers happen during the trip). Internal barriers include intrinsic and economic barriers, intrinsic barriers are factors such as the lack of knowledge about a destination, there is the worry about having appropriate social skills, there are also concerns over health issues and whether travel is seen as the right thing to do. Economic barriers are the worries over the affordability of travel. Exogenous barriers include environmental and interactive. Environmental barriers are the concerns over safety, rules and regulations, even paths and trails. Interactive barriers include concerns over attitudes of the workers and the accuracy of information provided. (Kwai-sang Yau, et al 2004)

There is much speculation that if these barriers where removed that there will be an increase in tourism participation. Under the DDA progress is been made to remove some of these barriers. Under the DDA it has been made illegal for service providers to discriminate against a person with a disability. Under the DDA any service provider that provides a service to the public in the UK, has the duty to make their services accessible to someone with a disability.

It is clear from the literature that travel among disabled people is not as simple as it would be for someone without a disability. There are a number of social and physical barriers that have to face even before the act of travel has even taken place. It may in fact be true that that removing these barriers would increase the tourism participation rates. Much work is been done by service providers to ease the physical barriers, however the social barriers need to be removed too; this is beyond the limitations of the tourism suppliers.


Referencing
Directgov. (2010). Tourism and the Disability Discrimination Act. Available: http://www.direct.gov.uk/en/DisabledPeople/TravelHolidaysAndBreaks/TravelAndHolidaysInTheUk/DG_4019030. Last accessed 21 March 2010

Kwai-sang Yau, M, McKercher, B and Packer,T.(2004) Traveling with a disability. Annals of Tourism Research,. 31 (4), 946-960

Page,S,.Connell,J,.(2006).Tourism a modern synthesis. 2nd ed.Britain :Thomson Learning .74-75.


Barriers Faced By a Disabled Tourist: A Response
Author: Juha Alho
I have chosen to respond on this paper because it shares a similar theme with my discussion paper and therefore it was interesting to observe your findings with the issues faced by disabled tourists. The topic is also becoming increasingly important part of the tourism industry and therefore it is very suitable for further discussion in this conference.

As setting a scene for discussion you have used the relevant statistics well and it is clear that the number of tourists with disabilities can be considered to be even surprisingly high as the group includes many different forms of physical and mental impairments which are all affecting on their participation on tourism. However to overcome these limitations is at least troublesome and as the literature you have used shows the development made in order to understand the issue with tourism and disabilities where the main focus is usually on physical barriers and on mobility of disabled people.

After 1995 when Disability Discrimination Act came into force the tourism industry has experienced a change due to the fact that it is the suppliers and service providers who are strongly responsible to make their products more accessible for disabled tourists. The text uses mainly two different frameworks for academic discussion which have been developed for better understanding on disabled tourists and the paper clearly points out that there are several issues making the disabled people's tourism participation a complex process.

The point you have made in the end of your paper stating: "Much work is been done by service providers to ease the physical barriers, however the social barriers need to be removed too; this is beyond the limitations of the tourism suppliers" suggests clearly that it is not just the industry's responsibility to increase disabled people's tourism participation and that there are also other factors to be taken under consideration in order to make tourism more 'disabled-friendly'. This is supported by Smith (1987) who states that 'it is the responsibility of both industry professionals and travellers with disabilities to reduce barriers to tourism participation' (cited in Daniels et al (2005), pp 921). However I think that to make your point stronger and credible there is a need for depth especially with the part demanding that something has to be done with the social barriers.

You have presented well the other factors affecting on disabled people's tourism participation; as the social dimension and the internal barriers are mentioned in your paper providing a short and pithy picture over the possible limitation-factors which are experienced by disabled tourists, however there is no further information how these things are really experienced on more practical level, not to mention on to what extension these barriers are affecting on them. Because of this, the text results giving a large number of issues to overcome and in the end it only states that these issues should be dealt with without making any further reasoning, suggestions, or efforts to find out why these non-physical barriers are not been dealt with before.



References:

Daniels, M. J. et al. (2005), '"Travel Tales": an interpretive analysis of constraints and negotiations to pleasure travel as experienced by persons with physical disabilities', Tourism Management, Vol. 26, pp 919-930

Office of Public Sector (OPSI), (2010), Disability Discrimination Act 1995 [online], Acts, OPSI, Available from: http://www.opsi.gov.uk/acts/acts1995/ukpga_19950050_en_4, [accessed 23.04.2010]

Lovelock, B. A. (2009), 'Planes, trains and wheelchairs in the bush: Attitudes of people with mobility-disabilities to enhanced motorised access in remote natural settings', Tourism Management, Vol. 31 (2010), pp 357-366

Burns, N. et al. (2009), 'An inclusive outdoors? Disabled people's experiences of countryside leisure services', Leisure Studies, Vol. 28 (4), pp 403-417